Posted: June 27th, 2015

Volunteer tourism promotes intercultural exchanges that rationalize poverty and reinforces tourism as neo-colonialism Volunteer tourism

Volunteer tourism promotes intercultural exchanges that rationalize poverty and reinforces tourism as neo-colonialism

Volunteer tourism

Introduction

Volunteer tourism also called voluntourism or international volunteering can be defined as the type of tourism whereby tourists voluntarily organize themselves and use their holidays in visiting places with positive reasons or objectives. The objectives may include; helping the needy groups in the society, bringing polluted environments into restoration or doing research of unique environment or societies around the world. For instance, the organized tourists may start projects that might help societies to preserve and conserve their environment or even educate them on community welfare. Good examples of volunteer tourist include; the Non Governmental organizations, Agencies for conservation, the sending companies, religious organizations, governments, among many others. (Wearing, 2001)

Volunteer tourism development

According to the Tourism Research and marketing (TRAM), volunteer tourism started just started few years ago and has become a global phenomenon with predictions of expansion or growth in the near future. (Mintel, 2008) The growth of volunteer tourism product in the market place is as a result of other emerging organizations offering the same services, but indirectly digging from the pockets of the people in societies.in defining correctly the term volunteer tourism, a study to understand volunteer tourism was conducted. (Carlsen & Charters, 2007)

Grounded theory was developed whereby the voluntourists were interrogated with the help of the questionnaires. The questionnaire was created in a design that encouraged people to complete it. The questions were simple to answer and not ambiguous. For instance, the questions were asking the volunteers; what they would do on the project, how they would spend their free time, what they understood by the term , international volunteering and the reasons that made them to participate in that type of holiday. (Goulding, 2002)

The data collected in the questionnaires were reviewed, coded, contrasted and analysis was made. This was done in order to allow categories of themes related to volunteer tourism to emerge. A core category of engagement emerged accompanied by its concepts and their properties. The examples of the concepts were; participation, integration, interaction, immersion, involvement among others. People responding that they ‘will be assisting workers in the children’s home and attending the children’s needs, helping the project to attain its set goals’ indicated that the tourism involved activity engagement to farther charitable causes. (Brink, 2007)

Another concept of volunteer tourism is volunteer work. Its concepts are choice, range, payment, time and purpose. As for the concept of choice, voluntourists had a right to make their own choice when it came to picking projects, area preferences, providers for voluntourism and many others. The range concept provided a range of projects for example; humanitarian projects which required the voluntourist to have knowledge to improve peoples’ life through health, education, construction e. t. c, projects for conservation which involved protection of animals, plants, lands, buildings e. t. c and controlling disasters. The voluntourists were to pay some amount of money to cater for them in the volunteer tourism (concept of payment.) Time, also a concept of volunteer work was for indicating the duration the work was supposed to take. The purpose concept was used to ensure that the volunteer work served the project, the provider and the voluntourist. (Rieckon, 1952)

A concept of tourist, also one of the categories of volunteer tourism was innovated to motivate people to become voluntourists. This category included sub-concepts and properties that are countless. It indicated almost all the objectives or reasons that made people to become voluntourists. The examples include; exploring, to learn, to meet new people and make new friends, cultural exchange, to see another culture, to spread personal beliefs, cultural immersion, to escape, to see another part of the world and very many other reasons. Some could give positive reasons e. g wanting to be of service to others, to improve other peoples’ lives, to give back, to assist, to spread skills and many voluntary reasons. (Smith, Hart Robertson &Macleod, 2009)____

Intercultural exchanges

Every society has its own culture. Acquired in early childhood, culture controls lives of many individuals. Every individual sees his or her culture as the perfect one and it is because of that strong believe that the culture enables them to choose between acceptable and unacceptable behavior. Defining culture is easy as it keeps on changing. Many societies are heterogeneous, that is why it is not easy to tell whether a certain society’s culture is a dominant one or it is typical. An intercultural exchange involves sharing of different peoples’ life by copying behaviors from one another. Traditionally, communities in societies restricted their people from adopting different cultures from the outside societies. (O’Dowd, 2007).

In the countries that were more advanced, the citizens saw the citizens of the developing countries as primitive and even associated them with animals. On return, the citizens in the developing countries criticized cultures of the developed countries. For instance, they viewed their way of dressing as unclean and not recommendable. I agree alit with those who oppose intercultural exchange but warn them that there is too much good for societies who share some of their beliefs (culture) and for real, the benefits of this are uncountable. Individuals, communities, societies and nations at large are of no exception when it comes to benefiting from intercultural exchanges. (Jack & Phipps, 2005)

Some of the factors that affect the nature of intercultural exchanges in the volunteer tourism are; the type of the identities of culture, race, ethnicity, gender role, social class, age, role and individual personality. The cultural identity talks of the norms and practices people adopt and practice in their communities or societies and how they differ from those of other people brought up in different societies. The racial identity affects the people of different races in the workplace who come from different cultures. Ethnicity, another factor affects the interaction of two people from different ethnic groups in the work place. (Gudykunst, 2005).

Societies view the roles of men and women from different perspectives. (Gender role identity factor) Another factor is that of social class identity. The level an individual possesses in the society determines how they will interact with other people in the workplace. The individual personality factor determines how a person communicates with others from different cultures depending on his or her own personality and where they rank themselves. (Ting-Toomey, 1999).

The age factor determines how different age groups of people from different cultures relate with one another. The culture of the United States is less mindful of their elders and hence the probability of taking their advice into account is very low but in countries like China, Cambodia and Thailand pay great attention to the advice of their elders and take it into account when it comes to deciding on important matters. SINGLETON, D. M., & RYAN, L. (Singleton &Ryan, 2004).

Volunteer tourism and intercultural exchange

I agree that volunteer tourism also called voluntourism or international tourism promotes intercultural exchange that rationalize poverty and reinforces tourism as neo-colonialism. Quite a number of researches conducted have proven this .an example is the establishment of American Field Service (AFC) in 1914. Originally, the organization belonged to a corps of civilian volunteers who used to drive ambulances to battlefields, during the first and second world wars. Since 1947, the American Field Service has been working hard to influence nations preaching international understanding and peace by promoting volunteerism and intercultural exchange programs in high schools. Students are taught about the importance of cultural exchange by their teachers. (Lengel, 2004).

The organization is now one of the largest organizations in the world with branches in 52 countries and another 30 countries with the program activity. Hong Kong and china are two good examples of the countries where the program has been established are. In Hong Kong, the high school students under take the course, some in short term and others year- long. In developing commitment to the philosophy of volunteerism, students and the American Field service volunteers take part in the community service activities.(Kenny, 2002)

AFS in China was started in1983 in partnership with China Association for International Educational Exchange (CAIEE) many Chinese teachers have been placed in schools in different countries to teach about cultural exchange with their international counterparts. A cultural exchange programme was launched in China in the year 1997.Students from the developing nations are often provided scholarship support by the American Field Service which sources the funds from private and corporate donors. (Moore, Walton & Lambert, 1992).

 

In a case of Indonesian tourists in Australia, it is clear to anyone with the knowhow of the story, that the greater the intercultural exchange, the more they need of awareness, understanding and acceptance of differences in culture by the tourism practitioners. The cultural differences between the two nations helped the two nations realize the need of cultural understanding in staffing people in the tourism industry sector. If there were no cultural differences, the behavior of every participant would have been understood and cultural conflicts would have been done away with. (Yunus & Weber, 2007).

A research by Parasuraman et al. (1994, J. of Marketing 58, 111–124) which argued that expectation measurement measures the service quality was conducted and the evidence presented by Cronin and Taylor (1994; op. cit.), and no cross-cultural samples were involved. It was proved wrong by another research that involved cross cultural samples. The study came up with an answer that expectations that appeared to be significant existed between cultural groups and that the expectation measurement did not improve the service quality. The study concluded that customer satisfaction, customer preferences, quality of services and retaining them was influenced by the encounters between different groups with different cultural values. (Market Research Society, 1963).

A cross cultural study on casino guests as perceived by the casino employees is another reason that should make one appreciate cultural exchange which is instrumented by volunteer tourism. In Korea, the casino industry is viewed as a tool for developing the economy. It is accepted as product of tourism which has encouraged tourism development. A research study’s objective was to learn more about the cultural elements that led to the interaction between the workers in Korea’s largest casino and the guests. (Dwyer, Gill & Seetaram, 2012).

The visitors (tourists in this case) were grouped into five cultural groups which include; the Japanese, the Chinese, the abroad Korean residents, the westerners and the others (Sri Lankan, Philippines, Thai e. t. c). Each group responded differently to the services offered by the employees. Some groups’ cultures almost resembled each other. Through the way the employees perceived the guests from each cultural group, the management benefited a lot by learning about dislikes and likes of each group. The cultural differences helped the management to develop new skills in marketing, staffing and providing quality services to the guests (Tourists). (Prideaux, Moscrdo & Laws, 2005).

The casino management was then able to make corrections on the type of games available and the range of services it would provide. The management too considered formal training program development to the employees that incorporated cultural training to better the understanding of cultural behaviors of different nations. From the study, we learn that the cultural exchange did not only benefit the Walker Hill Casino, but also benefited the people of Korea and the economy at large. We also learn the importance of gaming in the tourism sector as one way of promoting cultural exchange. (Uysal & Perdue, 2012).

Tourism in Burma is the other evidence I will use in agreeing with the statement that- Volunteer tourism promotes intercultural exchanges that rationalize poverty and reinforces tourism as neo-colonialism. The history of tourism in Burma can be divided into three; the parliamentary democracy, the socialist period and the period of the opening up of the tourist market. (Hallet & Kaplan, 2010)

In the period of parliamentary democracy, the economic policy of Burma towards capitalism was oriented. The tourist visas were valid for a month and Tourist Burma was assigned with informing and guiding tourists. When it reached 1962, the validity was reduced to 24 hours. This was aimed by the authority to reducing tourism in the country in order to protect the traditional culture from foreign influences. In 1990, the military government took power from a dictator and looked for a new strategy to open market for foreign investment. In 1992, the Ministry of Tourism and Hotels was established and this led to development of infrastructures of tourism. (Miller & Twining, 2005).

It is in 1996 when the junta opened door for tourists. The reasons why the junta prioritized tourism were; economic necessity and to regain prestige. The Burma nation benefited in tourism by sourcing foreign currencies to buy arms that military dictatorships needed in order to stay in power. The generals also wanted to show the other nations a new face of Burma through trips organized by the government, hiding or putting undercover, the political and human rights disasters. Come the year 2000, the tourists’ entry requirements were eased to motivate the volunteer tourists into the Burmese land and the validity period of visa was increased. In the year 2004, an electronic visa was introduced, which became possible to acquire in the mid of 2010 immediately after the tourists’ arrival to airports. This greatly facilitated the tourists into entering the Burmese land. (Hanne, 2008)

The growth of tourism has helped the third world countries to ‘see light’ i. e move from underdevelopment and become developed countries. The third world governments have promoted tourism because they have seen how it can transform nations that are underdeveloped. Tourism is also the source of income and employment. You cannot compare it with any other export industry in a nation. It impacts a nation’s economy positively. The tourists’ expenditure for example; parking and admission fees, taxes for local businesses hotels and services, generates income for both the public and the private sectors. (James, 1996)

In relation to tourist development is a case study comparing wine tourism destinations, Canada’s Okanagan Valley of British Columbia and the Niagara. The communities in the Okanagan relied on long hot summers and mild winters in attracting tourists. Wine tourism was later on built to ensure the strong captive market during the winter season. Challenges evolved include; a challenge to attract tourists, outside the short seasons of summer, a challenge of targeting a very small local population, limited land for agriculture and fear of inadequate water in the future. (Dougherty, 2012)

Despite the challenges, the industry managed to grow in a short period of about two decades; it had a nice production and quality wines. The number of wineries and the land available for vineyards then, became smaller to handle the project. A comparison of the two wine tourism destinations of Canada; the Okanagan and the Niagara wine region was conducted. Thirty eight grape wineries in Niagara were contrasted to 44 wineries in the Okanagan. (Low & Burstyn, 2005)

The Niagara’s wineries emerged to be the best because it was bigger in size and had a strong tourism orientation. Most of the Okanagan wineries did not have websites at the time the comparison was being made. The Niagara led because the region was highly populated; it had natural resources abundantly and was surrounded by features that easily developed. The examples of the developments in the Niagara Falls were; additional accommodations, hotels and restaurants, institutions that taught cooking and retail operations. (Chambers & Dearden, 2008).

One of the bases of comparisons and benchmarking found that it is not a must that all wine regions should have the same yield and power to develop. This is obvious especially when you compare the case of Niagara and that of Okanagan. (Cours, Elliott &Hernderson, 2001)

Despite of all the challenges, the Okanagan had a best side too; summer tourist attraction favored it, good infrastructure and migration of people from the rural to urban, making the population of the urban centers to grow. Being a tourist attraction, the residents of the Okanagan benefited a lot from the tourists for instance in securing job opportunities, learning more about agriculture from the foreigners, cultural exchanges and many more. The nation too was not left behind as it generated foreign exchange hence economic growth; the cultural exchange helped the nation build good interrelations with other nations and many more. (Getz, 2000)

International tourism also referred to as voluntourism or volunteer tourism promotes intercultural exchanges which helps nations learn from one another (mutual learning). A comparison of tourism policies of Hong Kong and Singer pore can evident this statement. The research study was conducted to show how mutual learning affected the competitiveness and sustainability of Singer pore and Hong Kong. (Carty, 2010).

The two nations have many similarities and it is this having many things in common that led the researchers into surveying them.When the top official of the government was interrogated about the interrelationships between the two countries, they agreed that there is a lot they share due to intercultural exchanges. The Hong Kong government can get ideas from Singer pore about the proactive help it applies to industries, leadership with vision and the eagerness the country has to learn. In correspondence to that, the Singer pore government can learn from Hong Kong, how to promote entrepreneurship within the industry of tourism. This mutual learning helps both nations to grow economically and creates good interrelationships hence promoting peace and harmony. (Wright &Kelly-Holmes, 1997).

Conclusion

International tourism also called volunteer tourism is one of the largest industries in the world that creates and promotes economic and social growth more so for poor nations. When the poor countries get established, its citizen too benefit from the transformation. The poor countries’ major export is tourism, and it is the major source of their foreign exchange. Countries that have received boost from tourism should ensure that, as their economy grows and so should be the standards of living for its citizens.

This can be achieved by making changes in institutions, laws, controls and functions that may help in doing away with poverty. As the nation benefits from international tourism, its citizens should be guaranteed opportunities to improve their economic and social lives.

Tourism is of great importance and should be encouraged at all costs. It facilitates Cultural exchange which if well applied can impact positively to every nation, society, community and the individuals. It has helped the poor people to become part of the processes that run the industry, educating them a lot, many of which they could have not discovered if left in their separate worlds.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

References;

WEARING, S. (2001). Volunteer tourism: experiences that make a difference. New York, CABI Pub.

CARLSEN, J., & CHARTERS, S. (2007). Global wine tourism research, management and marketing. Wallingford, CABI Pub. http://site.ebrary.com/id/10157942.

GOULDING, C. (2002). Grounded theory: a practical guide for management, business and market researchers. London [u.a.], SAGE.

BRINK, A. V. D. (2007). Imaging the future: geo-visualisation for participatory spatial planning in Europe. Wageningen, Wageningen Academic Publ.

RIECKEN, H. W. (1952). The volunteer work camp: a psychological evaluation. Cambridge, Mass, Addison-Wesley Press.

WRIGHT, S., & KELLY-HOLMES, H. (1997). One country, two systems, three languages: a survey of changing language use in Hong Kong. Clevedon, England, Multilingual Matters.

CARTY, H. (2010). An analysis of the economic torts. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

 

COERS, M., ELLIOTT, S., & HENDERSON, C. (2001). Benchmarking a guide for your journey to best-practice processes. Houston, American Productivity & Quality Center. http://www.lib.sfu.ca/cgi-bin/validate/books24x7.cgi?isbn=1928593240.

SMITH, M., HART ROBERTSON, M., & MACLEOD, N. (2009). Key concepts in tourist studies. London, Sage.

GETZ, D. (2000). Explore wine tourism: management, development & destinations. New York, Cognizant Communication.

LOW, J., & BURSTYN, M. (2005). Kitchen for kids: 100 amazing recipes your children can really make. Sydney, Murdoch Books.

JAMES, V. U. (1996). Sustainable development in Third World countries: applied and theoretical perspectives. Westport, Conn. [u.a.], Praeger.

MILLER, G., & TWINING-WARD, L. (2005). Monitoring for a sustainable tourism transition: the challenge of developing and using indicators. Wallingford, Oxfordshire, Angleterre, CABI Pub.

O’DOWD, R. (2007). Online intercultural exchange: an introduction for foreign language teachers. Clevedon, Multilingual Matters.

JACK, G., & PHIPPS, A. M. (2005). Tourism and intercultural exchange: why tourism matters. Clevedon, Channel View Publications.

UYSAL, M., & PERDUE, R. R. (2012). Handbook of tourism and quality-of-life research: enhancing the lives of tourists and residents of host communities. Dordrecht [etc.], Springer.

CHAMBERS, M., & DEARDEN, L. (2008). Frommer’s Niagara region. Mississauga, ON, Wiley.

DOUGHERTY, P. H. (2012). The geography of wine regions, terroir and techniques. Dordrecht, Springer. http://public.eblib.com/EBLPublic/PublicView.do?ptiID=885927.

HANNE., J. (2008). Tourism in Burma: blight or blessing? : the political dimensions of tourism in non-democratic countries and the question of responsible business in irresponsible environments : the case of Burma. Breda, NHTV Breda University of Applied Sciences.

GUDYKUNST, W. B. (2005). Theorizing about intercultural communication. Thousand Oaks [u.a.], Sage Pub

TING-TOOMEY, S. (1999). Communicating across cultures. New York, Guilford Press.

SINGLETON, D. M., & RYAN, L. (2004). Language acquisition: the age factor. Clevedon [u.a.], Multilingual Matters.

LENGEL, E. G. (2004). World War I memories: an annotated bibliography of personal accounts published in English since 1919. Lanham, Md. [u.a.], Scarecrfow Press.

KENNY, M. (2002). Learning to serve: promoting civil society through service learning. Boston, Mass, Kluwer Academic Publishers.

MOORE, S. J., WALTON, A. R., & LAMBERT, R. D. (1992). Introducing Chinese into high schools: the Dodge initiative. Washington, D.C., National Foreigin Language Center.

YUNUS, M., & WEBER, K. (2007). Creating a world without poverty: social business and the future of capitalism. New York, PublicAffairs.

MARKET RESEARCH SOCIETY. (1963). Market research abstracts. London, Market Research Society.

DWYER, L., GILL, A., & SEETARAM, N. (2012). Handbook of research methods in tourism: quantitative and qualitative approaches. Cheltenham, Edward Elgar

PRIDEAUX, B., MOSCARDO, G., & LAWS, E. (2005). Managing tourism and hospitality services: theory and international application. Cambridge, MA, CABI Publishing.

HALLETT, R. W., & KAPLAN-WEINGER, J. (2010). Official tourism websites: a discourse analysis perspective. Bristol, England, Channel View Publications.